County Commons · the United States

The transparency meter: what earns each box

Everyone agrees government should be open about its money and its work. This page sets out exactly what County Commons checks on every county page, the bar for each box, and a real government that already meets that bar. A perfect score is all 30: every dollar traced to its receipt, and every meeting and vote on the record.

How it works

Every box a county doesn’t meet is a petition. On any county page, each box that isn’t met links to a petition asking that county to publish it — counted by town, delivered to the county’s governing body at the goal, and marked answered when the box turns green. See every information petition →

Each item is yes, partly or no, with a plain note and a link to the page that proves it. An item nobody has checked says not checked yet, and that never counts against a county. Checks come from the budget books and state reports County Commons has read, federal and state audits, and visits to each county’s own website. We count what is public; we don’t judge why something isn’t. A county that publishes something we missed can tell us with the box on any page, and we fix it in public.

The bar for “yes” is set where the best governments already are, so it’s reachable. Two bars nobody has fully reached yet: the receipt behind every payment, and every payment posted the day it’s made by every county.

The 30 items

1. The plan — the budget

ItemThe bar for “yes”Who meets it
Proposed budget firstThe proposed budget is posted before the governing body votes on it, so people can weigh in.Georgia and New Zealand, top scorers (87 of 100) on the 2023 Open Budget Survey
Adopted budgetThe adopted budget is free to read online.Georgia and New Zealand, top scorers (87 of 100) on the 2023 Open Budget Survey
CurrentThe budget for the fiscal year now under way is posted.Georgia and New Zealand, top scorers (87 of 100) on the 2023 Open Budget Survey
By officeSpending is shown department by department.—
Line itemsInside each office, it shows what the money buys, like salaries, supplies and contracts.—
Adds upThe parts add to the total the county prints. County Commons checks this itself.—
Plain-language summaryA short “citizens budget” explains the budget in everyday words.Georgia and New Zealand, top scorers (87 of 100) on the 2023 Open Budget Survey
HistoryAt least five years of budgets and three years of payments stay online.the Texas Comptroller’s Transparency Stars criteria

2. Open format — can people and tools use it

ItemThe bar for “yes”Who meets it
SearchableThe budget is text or a spreadsheet, not a scanned picture.—
Open to toolsIt downloads without a bot check, so apps and research tools can read it.—
Open dataBudget or spending numbers come as a spreadsheet or data feed anyone can download.Checkbook NYC (New York City Comptroller)
Free to useNo sign-in, fee or license is needed to read, download or reuse it.—

3. What happened — what really came in and went out

ItemThe bar for “yes”Who meets it
Reports during the yearMonthly or quarterly reports compare spending so far with the budget.Georgia and New Zealand, top scorers (87 of 100) on the 2023 Open Budget Survey
Actual spendingA year-end report shows what the county really spent, not just the plan.—
Where money comes fromEach tax, fee and grant the county takes in is shown.—
AuditAn independent audit or state review is public.—
DebtWhat the county owes, to whom, and the yearly payments are shown.the Texas Comptroller’s Transparency Stars criteria
PensionsRetirement promises to workers, and how well funded they are, are shown.the Texas Comptroller’s Transparency Stars criteria

4. Every dollar — down to the receipt

ItemThe bar for “yes”Who meets it
Every paymentEach payment is listed with who was paid, how much and when, posted at least every three months.England’s councils, under the Local Government Transparency Code 2015
Card spendingPurchases on county credit or purchasing cards are listed.England’s councils, under the Local Government Transparency Code 2015
ContractsEvery contract award is posted with the company and amount, and the contract itself can be read.England’s councils, under the Local Government Transparency Code 2015
Pay by jobWhat each county job pays is public.Checkbook NYC (New York City Comptroller)
Tax breaks and dealsTax abatements and economic development deals show who got what, and what they promised.the Texas Comptroller’s Transparency Stars criteria
ReceiptsThe invoice or receipt behind each payment can be seen. We haven’t found any government that does this for every payment yet.—

5. Every action — meetings, votes and records

ItemThe bar for “yes”Who meets it
Agendas and minutesAgendas are posted before meetings and minutes after.—
VotesHow each elected official voted is recorded and posted.—
VideoMeetings are streamed or recorded, and the recordings are posted.—
Records requestsA log of public records requests and how each was answered is posted.—
Officials’ filingsThe financial disclosure filings of every elected county official can be read online.—

6. Speed — the top of the scale

ItemThe bar for “yes”Who meets it
Daily or real timePayments are posted within a day or in real time, not months later.Checkbook NYC (New York City Comptroller)

Who sets the bar

Counties checked so far — 49 with a website check

Most of the 3,144 counties haven’t had a website check yet, so their pages show many “not checked yet” boxes. These are the counties we’ve looked at, most items met first. Every number links to its county’s page, where each box has its proof.

CountyMetPartlyNot metNot checked
Garland County, Arkansas17670
Cook County, Illinois151014
Allegheny County, Pennsylvania140016
El Paso County, Texas140016
Nassau County, New York140016
Hennepin County, Minnesota130017
Los Angeles County, California130017
Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania130116
Clark County, Arkansas125130
Cuyahoga County, Ohio122016
Fairfax County, Virginia121017
Broward County, Florida120018
Franklin County, Ohio120018
Collin County, Texas111018
Denton County, Texas111018
Miami-Dade County, Florida111018
Wake County, North Carolina111018
Bell County, Texas110019
Lubbock County, Texas110019
Orange County, Florida110019
Riverside County, California110019
Tarrant County, Texas110019
Travis County, Texas110019
Fort Bend County, Texas102018
Suffolk County, New York102018
Bexar County, Texas101019
Hillsborough County, Florida101019
Fulton County, Georgia100020
King County, Washington100020
Mecklenburg County, North Carolina100020
Wayne County, Michigan100119
Alameda County, California91020
Montgomery County, Texas91020
San Diego County, California91020
Cameron County, Texas90021
Contra Costa County, California90021
Harris County, Texas90021
Maricopa County, Arizona90021
Orange County, California90021
Sacramento County, California90021
Salt Lake County, Utah90021
Hidalgo County, Texas82020
Clark County, Nevada81021
Dallas County, Texas70023
Galveston County, Texas60123
Santa Clara County, California50124
Williamson County, Texas50124
Brazoria County, Texas40125
Nueces County, Texas40125